From what I saw and read, people got super suspicious after Scarlett Johansson's SNL finale because the goodbye at the end was really quick. Fans always look for clues during the last episode of the season, like if someone hugs longer or seems weepy. Bowen Yang giving out hugs and looking extra emotional kind of set off the rumors because he’d even joked in an interview before about maybe leaving. Plus, Mikey Day and Heidi Gardner were pretty sentimental too, which made everyone wonder who’s actually staying. It’s kinda wild how fans act like detectives every season just cuz SNL cast changes are usually a big deal, especially after huge milestones like Season 50. Personally, I think the show keeps it secret on purpose so people talk and pay attention for news about next season. But yeah, as soon as the group started hugging and then the credits cut fast to commercial, I was legit texting my friends like, "Wait, who’s leaving?" I guess for most fans, it's not just about the show but about keeping up with these personalities after watching them for years.